BuddhaJones
HOME | ABOUT | MOBILE | RSS | WHAT IS NICHIREN BUDDHISM? | HOW TO USE THIS SITE

Dorje Change Buddha III: fraud or...what?

by: brooke

Sat Feb 27, 2010 at 16:18:45 PM MST


A Buddhism expert sees similarities to Nichiren's teachings in the dharma promoted by a new center in Utah:

"Dorje Chang Buddha III has already begun the transmission of the Mahamudra of Liberation, the highest Buddha-dharma, that offers a shortcut or quick path to liberation from the sufferings of this world," she says. "This is the dharma that all living beings must learn to become Buddhas."

Charles Prebish, a Buddhism expert at Utah State University and director of the school's Religious Studies Program, has never heard of Dorje Change Buddha III, nor, he says, have any of his Buddhist studies colleagues.

He indicated that virtually no Western forms of Buddhism teach the idea of a "Dharma-Ending Age." In the 13th century, the Nichiren School of Buddhism in Japan argued that it had the right teaching for the age of "Mappo" or the "Decline of the Dharma," Prebish says. "I have never seen this concept used in the context of Chinese or Tibetan Buddhism."

Still, Prebish says, the group uses appropriate ideas and references -- although he is withholding judgment on the new master's claims.

Anyone have more info about this group?

brooke :: Dorje Change Buddha III: fraud or...what?
Tags: (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
BUDDHA III
Cracks me up, Buddha III
Who's grandpa Buddha?  Wouldn't he be a reincarnation of Shakyamuni also, creating a family lineage. I could just as easily say that I'm the karmic reincarnation of someone and experts in BS could put me through unprovable tests based on opinion. You can't argue faith. You can only discredit the person.

There have been allegations of fraud regarding Dorje Chang's activities in China before his 1999 arrival in the United States, and some scholars question the guru's credentials. But nothing has been proven definitely.

Just as a theologian, an expert in theology and the properties of external deities with no ability to be falsified because they are based on unprovable faith, it has always struck me as ludicrous to be a "credentialed" expert in metaphysics. Everyone here who reads, writes and thinks has the same qualifications as any supposed authority because all proof is subjective. Thus we are all equally credentialed experts.  


PS BUDDHA III
And how come it's always gender specific? Time for some more imagination in our charlatans.  

[ Parent ]
Thus we are all equally credentialed experts.
I don't agree that we are equal to credentialed experts. I think they can all be considered frauds while the uncredentialed may be honestly sharing insights they have found true for themselves.

[ Parent ]
Credentials
I apologize for being unclear and apparently sending a mixed message. Suffice it to say it is ludicrous having credentials for qualities that does not have falsifiability.  

[ Parent ]
FAITH IN CREDENTIALS
Someone is a priest in the Catholic Church so if I accept the authority of the church I accept that this person is legitimate. According to some Hindus if the Guru didn't have a Guru then he is not considered legitimate because he is not vouched for by some lineage. The zen master can make the pronouncement that someone is qualified to teach. If you really had faith that someone was an enlightened teacher you would accept them on their own. If you realize that you can not tell an enlightened teacher from a charlatan then you need some governing body that you have faith in to tell you who is who. But if you don't believe the authorities than their opinion carries no weight.  

[ Parent ]
Menu

Make a New Account

Username:

Password:



Forgot your username or password?


Message Boards

Search




Advanced Search

Wiki Links
Fuju-fuse

Nichiren Shoshu

Nichiren Shu

Nipponzan Myohoji

Rissho Kosei Kai

Shoshinkai

Bookshelf Classics

Buddha by Karen Armstrong

Buddhism Without Beliefs by Stephen Batchelor

Cutting Through Spiritual Materialism by Chogyam Trungpa

Modern Buddhist Healing by Charles Atkins

Opening the Heart of the Cosmos: Insights on the Lotus Sutra by Thich Nhat Hanh

Riding The Wheel To Wellness: A Buddhist Perspective On Life's Healing Gifts, Meditation, Prayer & Visualization by Charles Atkins

Shambhala: The Sacred Path of the Warrior by Chogyam Trungpa

Threefold Lotus Sutra by Bunno Kato

When Things Fall Apart: Heart Advice for Difficult Times by Pema Chodron

The Wisdom of No Escape by Pema Chodron

Zen Mind, Beginner's Mind by Shunryu Suzuki

Daily Feeds

Fraught Feeds

Sites to See

Angry Asian Buddhist

A Buddhist Catholic

Alltop Buddhism

Barbara's Buddhism Blog

Buddhism Examiner

Buddhist Channel

Daily Scoldings

The Endless Further

Former SGI Member Forum

Gohonzon Galleries

Gongyo on Line

How Cults Work

Jacqueline I. Stone

Lotus Sutra in English

Martin Bradley's Gosho Translations

The Nichiren Sangha

Nichiren's Coffeehouse

One City

Precious Metal

Rougebuddha

Ryuei's Books and Essays

SGI Obituaries

Shodaigyo Streaming

Smilin' Buddha Cabaret

Soka Gakkai Unofficial

Soka Member

Whiskey River

Worst Horse



HOME
Except where otherwise noted, content on this site is published under a Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial Share Alike License.
Read and participate at your own risk.

Powered by: SoapBlox